If you could play any other instrument, what would it be and why?

If you could play any other instrument, what would it be and why?

57replies
{{batchActionsCtrl.state.selectedCount}} {{batchActionsCtrl.state.selectedCount==1?'reply':'replies'}} selected Move Cancel
Oldest first
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Active threads
  • Popular
  • For me, I would love to be able to sing better! 

    I have taken voice lessons in the past and realize that it is a somewhat difficult instrument to master "your body!"

     

    I admire singers and their abilities so much.

    That's why I will be the first one to signup and learn on "tonebase voice" which a new vertical launching in 2024! 🎉

    Reply Like 6
    • Dominic Cheli very exciting what Tonebase is growing into! I have a dream teacher for Tonebase Voice: Joyce DiDonato! Looking forward to the launch.
      the instrument I would love to be able to play would be the violin. Would be cool to play in an orchestra. There is so much wonderful repertoire to discover!

      Reply Like 3
      • Daniel
      • Daniel.31
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Dominic Cheli I'd also say singing, but there's something about singing that makes me believe that I could train my voice only up to a certain level. And that more so than other instruments, it is easier for some people with naturally beautiful voices to sing more beautifully. Interested to see if there will be any lectures on tonebase voice on this subject. 

      Reply Like
      • Chi Mei Yang
      • A retired healthcare worker.
      • Chi_Mei_Yang
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Dominic Cheli  I took voice lessons from 2000-2003 and competed in local opera competition for two years.  I would be the first one to sign up for Tonebase Voice! Though my voice is not as good as before, I would like to go back to train my voice again. As for another instrument, I would love to learn to play marimba. Thank you.

      Reply Like
      • Pauline
      • Pauline
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Dominic Cheli How exciting to learn about "Tonebase Voice"! Thank you, Dominic!

      Reply Like
    • Dominic Cheli I've started to learn to sing in the past year and I'm stunned how far I've come. I really bought into the myth that you either have a beautiful voice or you don't... not so, it's like any instrument - just practice a little every day and you will get better!

      I don't personally have goals to become a professional singer or anything, but I have to say learning to sing has had huge benefits for my musicianship overall – especially with ear training and sight reading. Really helps with interval recognition and when looking at a piece of music, being able to sing the melody (or individual voices) before playing on piano helps me dig into a piece even faster with a greater understanding before I even put my fingers on the keyboard. I love the benefits and think every musician should learn to sing even a little bit :)

      I look forward to a Tonebase Voice too! 🙏

      Reply Like
    • Dominic Cheli Ditto that, sing. I guess I'll be the second person to join the Tonebase voice then, can't wait for the launch! I also play guitar but far more piano these days. No offense to the guitar folks, I was already practicing a bit this morning, it's just the analogy I use comparing guitar vs. piano is like juggling six shot puts versus ten ping pong balls. The former is heroically strenuous but the latter provides a more complex and interesting display, for me.  Bucket list is to have a pro-tier voice for my juggling licks and tricks to accompany. 

      Reply Like
  • I self taught and played the guitar during my university years when I was also recovering from an injury. It was really helpful therapy and probably saved my life.  I loved playing the calming renaissance music, and progresses to flamenco and Spanish music  and so pleased I could manage the 'Alhambra.' Then music dropped off completely when I started working.  I wish I could pick up the guitar again, but I think that would get in the way of my  piano progress. With piano,  I don't have fingernails for plucking the guitar.

     

    But I did sing in a symphonic chorus for a few years and even performed in opera choruses - some of my happiest times. Again wish I could join a chorus again but my voice has changed and I couldn't hit some high notes anymore (:

     

    But happy and satiesfied to keep working on the piano!

    Reply Like 3
  • If I had to do it all over again, I’d play French Horn. Such a beautiful sound.

    Reply Like 3
  • For me it would be oboe or bassoon. I played basson in high school & I love the tone of the double reed instruments. 
    Or maybe guitar, because it is beautiful, versatile, and can be taken anywhere. 

    Reply Like 4
    • Alberto
    • Alberto.1
    • 7 mths ago
    • Reported - view

    I hope one day put my hands on a clarinet, that instrument rocks

    Reply Like 3
  • I would love to be able to play the cello. I love the deep soothing sound and it would be nice to be able to just focus on the melody. 

    Reply Like 5
    • Vidhya Bashyam that would be my choice, too!

      Reply Like 2
      • Gail Starr
      • Retired MBA
      • Gail_Starr
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Vidhya Bashyam yup, I loved cello! Wish I could still play!

      Reply Like
  • I had a couple of years of oboe lessons during high school - love its rich and lyrical sound. I would love to play it again though I probably no longer have the lung capacity for it so ... thinking about a ukulele partly for the portability 😄

    Reply Like 3
  • I’d love to sing and accompany myself with a cuatro (it’s similar to an ukulele), so I can take it places, as we know piano is not portable! But this is for popular music, not classical at all :) I was in the chorus at the conservatory too and really loved choral music!

    Reply Like 3
  • If another instrument means an instrument I've never played but always rather wanted to.... then (if I had the time) it would be the 'cello. But that would have to include baroque 'cello. Why? Because I know almost nothing of string technique and would like to know something. Why the 'cello? Because of its delicious mellow sound, and the quality of the repertoire - most of all, of course, the works by Bach.

    If another instrument means an instrument I've played in the past and know I ought to resurrect, then that's the recorder. A much-maligned instrument because so often used so badly in schools, it is in fact a glorious thing (in fact, a whole set of instruments) with a wealth of repertoire available.

    If another instrument means an instrument other than the modern piano, then my only and profound wish would be to have more time for the virginals and clavichord, both of which I own and play but which tend to get crowded out by the organ. And I'd like to win the lottery so that I could buy a piano from every period - one for Mozart, one for Beethoven, one for Chopin. 

    Reply Like 1
    • Rodney
    • Rodney
    • 7 mths ago
    • Reported - view

    My father played trumpet in the big band days, and maybe I would like that, however, too tough on the lips.  Sorry, there is no competitive instrument for me.

        Thanks for asking.

    Reply Like 1
  • The violin. I just love the tone of the instrument, and are a bit jealous as a pianist of their ability to hold long notes and move around while playing. I also own a couple of violins, so would love to be able to play on them! 

    Reply Like 4
    • Sindre Skarelven I love it too but I tried and couldn’t even hold the bow correctly D:

      Reply Like 2
    • Paula Alizo Haha, yes, I suspect it would be many many hours of frustration before producing any decent tone, so we’re probably better of just admiring those who can play it :D 

      Reply Like 1
      • Kerstin
      • Kerstin
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Sindre Skarelven Hi Sindre, yes me too. I have a violin and took some lessons. But it’s really hard and I had no time for the piano. So I decided to play piano. There are a lot of wonderful concertos for violin. Which one do you like most? 
      LG Kerstin

      Reply Like 2
    • Kerstin Hi Kirstin, agreed! One concert I got to see this year was the Tchaikovsky concerto. I loved that one, played by Norwegian violin virtuoso Eldbjørg Hemsing. (She quite impressively stepped in for a sick Lisa Batiashvili on two days notice.) 

      In two weeks I get to see Janine Jansen play the Sibelius concerto. That one I also like! 

      Do you have any favorites, or recommendations? 

      Reply Like 1
      • Gail Starr
      • Retired MBA
      • Gail_Starr
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Sindre Skarelven violín was my first instrument!

      Reply Like 1
      • Kerstin
      • Kerstin
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Sindre Skarelven Hi Sindre! Tchaikovsky is wonderful and I love Saint-Saëns Introduction and Rondo Capriccioso. 
      There are so many great pieces. 😊

      Reply Like 1
  • Spam
    • Remove post
    • Remove and block user
  • Edit
  • Publish
  • Unschedule
  • Cancel event
  • Uncancel event
  • Set status
    • Clear status
  • Pin
  • Unpin
  • Bump
  • Open replies
  • Close replies
  • Clear flags
  • Move
    • Move to category:
    • Start Here
    • Welcome to the tonebase Piano Community!
    • New To tonebase? Click Here!
    • Piano Level System
    • News & Announcements
    • General Discussions
    • Tonebase Lesson Discussions
    • Ask Me Anything - New Guests Every Month!
    • General Discussion
    • Your Practice Diary
    • Discussion of the Week
    • 4-Hand Piano Hub!
    • Live Streams and Events
    • Live Calendar
    • Community Concerts!
    • Community Suggestions
    • Upcoming Challenges and Two Week Intensives!
    • Live Discussion Archive
    • Hidden Thread Repository
    • Community Challenges
    • A Fresh Start!
    • The Practice Plan Challenge!
    • End of the Year Challenge: "Showcase Your Progress
    • Franz Liszt Birthday Challenge!
    • Unfinished Business Challenge!
    • Mini Challenges
    • Lyrical Miniatures: A Sonorous Journey feat. Grieg
    • Celebrating Tchaikovsky's Birthday!
    • Community Challenges / Challenge Archive
    • The Pillars of Piano Technique (Mini-Challenge)
    • Celebrate Rachmaninoff's Birthday Challenge!
    • "Music YOU Love" Community Challenge!
    • Finding Colors in your sound (Mini Challenge!)
    • Preparing your pieces for Concert - A Checklist!
    • Mozart & Haydn - Music from the 18th Century! 🏰
    • Improvising Classically with George Ko!
    • The Music of France!
    • "Improve your Technique!" Month
    • February: Discovering Schubert Month
    • Bach in March
    • LONGTERM ONGOING - Bach's Goldberg Variations
    • tonebase Community Concert Challenge
    • Brahms Waltzes Challenge!
    • Beethoven Variations Community Challenge!
    • Tonebase Holiday Challenge!
    • Liszt's Soirées de Vienne Community Challenge!
    • Handel G-major Chaconne
    • Two Week Intensives
    • TWI: Improving your Scales!
    • Crash Course on Controlling your Dynamics!
    • Intensive Workshop: Compose your own Piano Piece!
    • TWI: What makes Schubert GREAT with Ben Laude
    • Improving your ability with the Left Pedal
    • Improve your Cantabile Playing with Dr. Garritson
    • Improve your Chopin Mazurkas with Jarred Dunn!
    • Narrative Musicianship w/ Konstantin Soukhovetski
    • Improvising a simple ABA Piece with Jeremy Siskind
    • General Information and Sign-Up!
    • Public Spaces!
    • Two Week Intensives / Two Week Intensive Archive
    • Lesson discussion archive
    • "Improving your rhythm!": Beyond the Metronome
    • "Becoming an Orchestra" TWI with Daniela Bracchi
    • Bach's Polyphony Intensive with Magdalena
    • Improve your MOZART sonata with Orli Shaham!
    • Improving your Sightreading with Leann Osterkamp!
    • Improve your Chopin Etudes with Henry Kramer!
    • Improve your Arpeggios with Claire Huangci
    • Improve Your Harmonic Analysis with Ben Laude
    • Improve your Chopin Ornaments with Jarred Dunn!
    • Improve your Scales!
    • Ask a Friend
    • Recommendations
  • Copy
    • Copy to category:
    • Current category
    • Start Here
    • Welcome to the tonebase Piano Community!
    • New To tonebase? Click Here!
    • Piano Level System
    • News & Announcements
    • General Discussions
    • Tonebase Lesson Discussions
    • Ask Me Anything - New Guests Every Month!
    • General Discussion
    • Your Practice Diary
    • Discussion of the Week
    • 4-Hand Piano Hub!
    • Live Streams and Events
    • Live Calendar
    • Community Concerts!
    • Community Suggestions
    • Upcoming Challenges and Two Week Intensives!
    • Live Discussion Archive
    • Hidden Thread Repository
    • Community Challenges
    • A Fresh Start!
    • The Practice Plan Challenge!
    • End of the Year Challenge: "Showcase Your Progress
    • Franz Liszt Birthday Challenge!
    • Unfinished Business Challenge!
    • Mini Challenges
    • Lyrical Miniatures: A Sonorous Journey feat. Grieg
    • Celebrating Tchaikovsky's Birthday!
    • Community Challenges / Challenge Archive
    • The Pillars of Piano Technique (Mini-Challenge)
    • Celebrate Rachmaninoff's Birthday Challenge!
    • "Music YOU Love" Community Challenge!
    • Finding Colors in your sound (Mini Challenge!)
    • Preparing your pieces for Concert - A Checklist!
    • Mozart & Haydn - Music from the 18th Century! 🏰
    • Improvising Classically with George Ko!
    • The Music of France!
    • "Improve your Technique!" Month
    • February: Discovering Schubert Month
    • Bach in March
    • LONGTERM ONGOING - Bach's Goldberg Variations
    • tonebase Community Concert Challenge
    • Brahms Waltzes Challenge!
    • Beethoven Variations Community Challenge!
    • Tonebase Holiday Challenge!
    • Liszt's Soirées de Vienne Community Challenge!
    • Handel G-major Chaconne
    • Two Week Intensives
    • TWI: Improving your Scales!
    • Crash Course on Controlling your Dynamics!
    • Intensive Workshop: Compose your own Piano Piece!
    • TWI: What makes Schubert GREAT with Ben Laude
    • Improving your ability with the Left Pedal
    • Improve your Cantabile Playing with Dr. Garritson
    • Improve your Chopin Mazurkas with Jarred Dunn!
    • Narrative Musicianship w/ Konstantin Soukhovetski
    • Improvising a simple ABA Piece with Jeremy Siskind
    • General Information and Sign-Up!
    • Public Spaces!
    • Two Week Intensives / Two Week Intensive Archive
    • Lesson discussion archive
    • "Improving your rhythm!": Beyond the Metronome
    • "Becoming an Orchestra" TWI with Daniela Bracchi
    • Bach's Polyphony Intensive with Magdalena
    • Improve your MOZART sonata with Orli Shaham!
    • Improving your Sightreading with Leann Osterkamp!
    • Improve your Chopin Etudes with Henry Kramer!
    • Improve your Arpeggios with Claire Huangci
    • Improve Your Harmonic Analysis with Ben Laude
    • Improve your Chopin Ornaments with Jarred Dunn!
    • Improve your Scales!
    • Ask a Friend
    • Recommendations
  • Change type
    • Change topic type to:
    • Discussion
    • Question
    • Idea
    • Issue
    • Article
    • Event
  • Restore post
    • Spam
    • Offensive
    • Inappropriate
    • Duplicate
    • Other
  • Remove post
    • Spam
    • Offensive
    • Inappropriate
    • Duplicate
    • Other
  • Publish
  • Spam
    • Remove post
    • Remove and block user
  • Edit
  • Pin
  • Unpin
  • Open replies
  • Close replies
  • Label
    • Clear label
  • Move
  • Clear flags
  • Restore post
    • Spam
    • Offensive
    • Inappropriate
    • Duplicate
    • Other
  • Remove
    • Spam
    • Offensive
    • Inappropriate
    • Duplicate
    • Other
Like Follow
  • 3 mths agoLast active
  • 57Replies
  • 360Views
  • 46 Following

Home

View all topics