Group 2

Welcome to the latest TWO WEEK INTENSIVE on tonebase!

 

For the next two weeks we will be working through assignments given by Lindsay Garritson to improve your Cantabile Playing

Pianists of all levels are welcome. 

 

More Detailed instructions coming soon!

  • Sign-Up : September 11
  • Course Period: September 18-October 2nd
  • Class Size: ALL are welcome!
  • Optional check-In via Zoom: 

September 28th at 11am Pacific Time

 

Join Zoom Meeting

https://us06web.zoom.us/j/84812603822?pwd=DUo16MYAj50zLwbmZ1fco9PKbYh6qb.1

Assignment #1 

"Singing at the Piano"

 

Description: How do we sing at the piano?

 

This is one of the most difficult yet rewarding things to achieve in our piano playing! We will look at the different technical components which go into creating a beautiful, singing sound. From transparent to rich textures, we will take sections from four pieces by Mendelssohn, Chopin, Brahms, and Ravel, and discuss the considerations required to achieve a resonant sound in each. 

 

Introduction video: https://youtu.be/UezTgcCsp7c

 

C Major Scale Exercise: https://youtu.be/Ug6BnzuTIHk

1) Record a one octave C major scale very slowly (right hand alone, then left hand alone), applying the "down - up" motion with every note, listening carefully for the quality of sound in each note and using as legato a touch as possible 

 

2) Record the same C major scale in both hands separately at a faster tempo, but applying the "down - up" motion over the entire pattern (not a separate motion for each note) 

 

Mendelssohn Songs without Words, Op. 19, No. 1: 

https://youtu.be/rXskBg5g9DU

 

1) Record the melody in the right hand alone (at a much slower tempo) from the upbeat of measure 3 until the downbeat of measure 15, listening for resonance of sound, legato articulation, observing places to "breathe" between phrases; don't worry about using the fingering that you will use when playing all parts together (the focus now is quality of sound and phrasing)

 

2) Record just the bass line in the left hand (also at a slower tempo), start from measure 3 until downbeat of measure 15, listening again for the quality of sound, special moments of harmonic change, legato articulation; again, don't worry about the fingering in this exercise (do what promotes the most legato touch)

 

3) Record the melody in the right hand as well as the bass line in the left hand (outer two lines), listening to how the "voices" are interacting (the energy between the two and how the left hand functions as a counter melody), as well as indicating clearly shaping within the phrases

 

4) Record all parts from upbeat of measure 3 to downbeat of measure 15, again slowly, listening particularly for control in the sixteenth notes and making sure they are at a dynamic which does not overpower the clarity and resonance of the melody in the right hand as well as the bass line in the left hand

 

Chopin Nocturne in C minor, Op. 48, No. 1: 

https://youtu.be/tsaDGdbAzdE

 

1) Record the "voicing" exercise: taking a C major chord in the right hand (C, E, G, C) and play the chord seven times in a row, highlighting one note at a time (middle C the first time, then the E the next time, and so forth) 

 

2) Record the melody in the right hand alone (top note of each chord) from measure 25 to downbeat of measure 37, listening for the legato between each note, resonance, attention to shaping within the phrases; don't worry about using the fingering you will be using once you play all of the notes (use what best promotes legato in this exercise)

 

3) Record all notes in the right hand alone, but WITHOUT pedal, trying to connect each chord where possible from top note to top note (melody); where physically it is not possible, try to give the illusion of legato through careful shaping of the chords (small crescendi, decrescendi, etc.)

 

4) Record all parts, hands together in the same section, WITH pedal, listening carefully to the voicing in each chord and listening to how well you connect the sound from chord to chord

 

---

 

WEEK #2 Assignment!

 

Brahms Intermezzo in A Major, Op. 118, No. 2: 

https://youtu.be/hftV4KIAn-g

 

1) Record top melody in the right hand alone from beginning to measure 16, focuses the legato touch, phrasing (important moments you are leading to and away from), adding a different "color" to the places Brahms writes dolce

 

2) Record the "alto" line in the right hand alone (same material), listening for the same qualities as in the first exercise

 

3) Record the left hand alone, listening for a richness and depth of sound, particularly in the low bass notes (think of the sound of a cello for inspiration) 

 

4) Put all parts together, slower than the original tempo, paying attention to the quality of sound between the soprano and alto lines (thinking of them as a duet, so one part is not necessarily more important than the other); listening for the depth of the bass notes in the left hand; taking time in moments you feel are important (larger intervals, between phrases, etc.)

 

Ravel Pavane pour une infante défunte: 

https://youtu.be/1NtbGZM75dA

 

1) Record the melody in the right hand alone from beginning to downbeat of measure 8, taking special care in listening to the notes with ties, making sure the notes coming immediately after each tied note are not louder (making sure you aren't adding any sort of accent to these notes); don't worry about using the fingering you will use when playing all parts in the right hand together

 

2) Record the "alto" line in the right hand alone (beginning to measure 6) WITHOUT pedal, listening to evenness of staccati articulation and seeing how little you can move your hand (relying on the staccato articulation with just the fingertips)

 

3) Record left hand alone WITHOUT pedal (same measures), taking care to use an articulation that is slightly longer than staccato (almost as if you are adding tiny tenuto marks to each note) 

 

4) Record all parts hands together WITH pedal (slowly), listening to the quality of your legato in the melody, evenness of staccati and softer dynamic of the"alto" line (even though it will not sound short with pedal), and a resonant sound in the left hand 

208replies Oldest first
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Active threads
  • Popular
  • Here are my Brahms videos. I worked on this years ago so was fun to bringing a little bit of it back and seeing what I need to work on.
     

    Ex 1- RH

    https://youtu.be/2x8K4M_9_u4?si=PQ4mi3K2taz1yfWK
     

    Ex 2- Alto

    https://youtu.be/JMZcPqXszz4?si=iG9fF_1TfoJFmSUF

    Ex3- LH

    https://youtu.be/dfNl4f0v7u8?si=6p6nvHYtizvhcZMD
     

    Ex 4- both hands

    Like 8
    • Vidhya Bashyam Beautifully sung, Vidhya!

      Like 2
    • Andrea Buckland Thanks Andrea!

      Like 1
      • Juan Carlos Olite
      • Philosophy teacher and piano lover
      • Juan_Carlos
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Vidhya Bashyam Tender and delicate playing, Vidhya! Sounds beautiful!

      Like 2
    • Vidhya Bashyam that is very beautiful and sensitive cantabile playing! I’ve always wanted to learn this piece.

      Like 2
    • Juan Carlos Olite Thank you!

      Like 1
    • Natalie Peh Thanks! This is one of my unfinished business pieces. I have gotten to the end but never went deep in the piece or made it performance ready. Even a little section feels good to play though.

      Like 2
      • Michelle R
      • Michelle_Russell
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Vidhya Bashyam So beautiful, Vidhya! I enjoy hearing the sensitivity and gentleness you bring to this piece.

      Like 1
    • Michelle R Thank you so much Michelle!

      Like
    • Vidhya Bashyam Thank you sharing, Vidhya! I love your sensitivity to the expression of the music, and you are getting a lovely sound in each note, but in the exercises as well as all parts together. You should definitely perform the whole thing at some point! I'm glad you've been enjoying revisiting. 

       

      My comments for the exercises overall were to try to employ that "down-up" motion where the two-note/chord slurs occur (not an exaggerated motion, but just a bit more than you were doing). I think these two-note slurs are what give the music a bit more energy than if Brahms had had just written a slur over the first three chords, for instance. They give it a bit more "life," so I wanted to see a little more of that in the exercises. But, you were still creating a lovely legato and sound! For all parts together, I wanted to hear more of a small decrescendo into the second beats of measures 4 and 8 (for the second beat of measure 8, work for an even better voicing/control of bringing out that top note). In the downbeats of measures 6 and 14, I wanted you to highlighting that top A even more; if you can use a bit more weight and emphasis on that A, the emotional impact of those comparable moments can be even more beautiful! One small comment on pedaling: for harmonic clarity, make sure to change the pedal more clearly in the third beats of measures 11 and 15. Overall, really beautiful playing! 

      Like
    • Lindsay Garritson Thank you again for the detailed feedback! I enjoyed  all the pieces in this TWI.

      Like 1
      • Gail Starr
      • Retired MBA
      • Gail_Starr
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Vidhya Bashyam You inspire me!  I'd love to learn this also.

      Like 1
    • Gail Starr I would love to hear you play it too! 

      Like 1
      • Gail Starr
      • Retired MBA
      • Gail_Starr
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Vidhya Bashyam We need to learn it together.  Maybe in November?  Too busy in October!

      Like
    • Marc M
    • Amateur piano enthusiast
    • Marc_M
    • 7 mths ago
    • Reported - view

    Here's my Chopin! That third exercise of no pedal RH sure was tough. For the last part, sorry for fudging some of the hands together chords...I really ought to put more work into the piece. The rolled chords simply aren't comfortable yet. But, I wanted to submit something while the TWI is still in progress. https://youtu.be/0Tqe2eBYdyE?si=TdKIfKuA_TICe4j6

    Edit: I’m going camping tomorrow (just a one night thing) so I wanted to bang out the Brahms today also…I might need to get that alto voice to sing a bit more when playing hands together. Here it is: https://youtu.be/5BjY9jD4LJA?si=-FneCJayMhk7rMVe

    Second Edit: Was able to squeeze in the Ravel before camping (now I'd better start packing...). Thank you, Lindsay, for these useful exercises, and thanks in advance for the feedback! https://youtu.be/LSLTMqx-L34?si=q-O2z59PP0uKjdIn

     

    P.S. And, here's the Mendelssohn, reposted from above, for when Lindsay has a chance to review. :) https://youtu.be/U1MXap8y6yo?si=6D14cFufGqHXwEmr

    P.P.S. Sadly, I can't make it to the check-in, but I'll be sure to review it when it's complete!

    Like 7
    • Marc M  nice work, putting up the videos before your trip! I am now away for 3 weeks with no piano, so I can only try and catch up later on! 

      Like 3
    • Marc M Everything sounds great! 

      Like 2
      • Michelle R
      • Michelle_Russell
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Marc M Great job, Marc! I enjoyed listening to the Brahms especially. Hope you had a good camping trip. 

      Like 2
    • Marc M Thank you so much for posting these, Marc! I'll have a chance to listen soon and comment.

      Like 2
      • Gail Starr
      • Retired MBA
      • Gail_Starr
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Marc M Great job, Marc!  And so organized to post BEFORE your camping trip.  When we used to camp often (thanks, Boy Scouts!), I was so overwhelmed with packing that I barely had time to cook dinner.

      Like 2
    • Marc M Thank you for posting these, Marc! Hope you're having a good camping trip. :)

       

      The voicing exercises are looking good! Good control already. For the Chopin exercises, you're doing a very nice job of shaping this melody over all the exercises. Small comment for fourth beat of 27: even though you will have the pedal down, I would still recommend keeping your fingers down for the duration of that dotted chord in the right hand (you'll creating even more resonance in this chord that way). I would also recommended at measure 31, fourth beat, that you implement a slight lift of the hand after you play that chord (the down-up motion I've discussed in general). I find that this kind of movement in this dramatic context (you have a chord, short rest, then another chord) can help both round off the end of the phrase as well as create a slight "breath" before moving onto the next phrase. Not an exaggerated movement, but something a bit more than what you were doing. Another comment is for the first half of measures 29 and 35: between those two chords in the right hand, I would implement a small decrescendo into the second chords of each of those measures. This will give the musical line even more smoothness. Good work with these! 

      Like
    • Marc M I enjoyed the Mendelssohn as well! You were very thoughtful in all the details of this, from dynamics to rounding off phrases. Your piano also sounds nice! I'm not familiar with Brodmann, but seems like a beautiful instrument to work with. For the exercise with right hand melody and left hand bass line together, I sometimes wanted to hear even more energy in the left hand: for instance, at measure 8 leading up to that fourth beat marked forte in the right hand, I thought your left hand (both in this exercise and all parts together) could have added just a bit more depth in each note as well as more of tenuto articulation on that fourth beat, providing a "cushion" (as I like to think about it sometimes) to the melody. In measure 13, I also felt the left hand could provide a little more energy against the right hand (like a dialogue in response to the right hand), so it might also help if you don't get so soft in the right hand in measure 12 (especially on that A#) in order to create a longer line and keep the energy (yes, it says diminuendo, but I don't interpret this as disappearing so much!). One small observation in the left hand at measure 6: I am used to hear this B natural in the bass line as having a tie. Does your edition note have a tie there? Just wanted to point this out in case! Beautiful work overall. 

      Like
      • Marc M
      • Amateur piano enthusiast
      • Marc_M
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Lindsay Garritson Thank you for your helpful feedback! I'll pay more attention to that left hand.  Really, my left hand is super awkward and clumsy compared to my right. I will need to work on that issue in general.

      Glad you like the Brodmann! It's a new CE175 that I bought earlier this year. The character of the sound changes a lot when playing quietly vs. louder--this made it easier to keep the broken chords distinct from the melody in Mendelssohn piece. Keeping the voices distinct on my previous piano would've been much more difficult.

      For the Mendelssohn, the edition I used (link) did not have a tie on measure 6. Now that you mention it, though, a tie there makes more musical sense.

      Thank you again for leading the 2 week intensive!

      Like 1
      • Marc M
      • Amateur piano enthusiast
      • Marc_M
      • 7 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Gail Starr Michelle R Vidhya Bashyam Natalie Peh Thank you for your kind words! It was a pleasure doing this TWI y'all and listening to everyone's hard work. Kudos, Group 2!

      Like 1
    • Marc M I will get to your Ravel in the next day! FYI

      Like 1
    • Marc M Great to hear you play!

      Like
Like3 Follow
  • 3 Likes
  • 6 mths agoLast active
  • 208Replies
  • 929Views
  • 19 Following

Home

View all topics