Choosing a reconditioned grand piano

Hi Aaron,

Since both pianos are “reconditioned” you are essentially looking at two new instruments so the year of manufacture doesn’t really matter. If I were you, I’d pick the C3 as it is longer, and typically using better materials than the G2 to begin with. However, I would strongly urge you to consider having ALL the hammers replaced. You’ll get a more uniform tone that way and not have to worry about further replacement in the near future. 

Hi,

I completely agree with Timothy, All things equal, I'd also pick the C3 and also encourage you to get all the hammers replaced (unless you don't care about tone).

Two things I'd add, is (1) make absolutely sure the pin block is good (no damage, not doped, no abuse, etc.) - generally all the pins will be roughly the same height and the strings should be the well above the plate at the pin. If possible, have a different technician verify it. Yamahas are extremely stable pianos, but if your pin block is bad, your "new" instrument may just be an expensive lesson. (2) Soundboards lose tension over time and will not respond quite the same as a factory fresh instrument, but I doubt the 17 year advantage of the G2 will compensate for the higher quality materials of the C3. Ultimately, let your ears guide you in this aspect.