How do many of you deal with performance anxiety?

I have a problem staying focused when I play in front of people. even when I play in my own home. I play okay, but I find that I lose my focus because I keep wondering how I sound to those listening to me. I make mistakes that I would never make in practice. Some are mistakes I never made before. How do some of you stay so focused? Is it just because I need more experience playing in front of people or are there other methods you all use?

20 replies

null
    • Barbara_Sunseri
    • 8 days ago
    • Reported - view

    I have the same issue!  No matter how much I've practiced, inevitably I make a mistake that surprises me - like I've never stumbled on that area in the music before.  I'm really working on increasing my exposure of playing in public so that I'm not so vulnerable to performance nerves and goofs.

    • Amanda_Clark
    • 8 days ago
    • Reported - view

    I am the same! All of a sudden numerous mistakes, even if my husband just walks in the room. I never perform to friends for this reason. I'm trying to get used to a 'sense' of performing by recording myself, but even that ends up with more mistakes than practice! V frustrating, & you're not alone with it.

      • Maria_Morando
      • Yesterday
      • Reported - view

       I learned from a guy that teaches knowledge about the mind in playing music. That When we play for ourselves we are at a higher attention and concentration level so we usually don’t make mistakes on the passages we feel confident in. When we are playing for an audience our level of concentration can deplete as much as 20 or 30%!!  I think that is why we mess up on stuff we usually play well. We are already not heavily focused on that part because we are well versed on it, but let that focus reduce by a significant percentage and they are often the first to get messed up! One time I was so nervous I couldn’t even play the first line of a song that I played for 3 years!! I guess it didn’t help that they were standing over my shoulder watching me. I blamed it on a glass of wine I had earlier. I really don’t think it was the wine! 

      • rebecca_LAM
      • Yesterday
      • Reported - view

       that is so true. When someone is watching me playing, I am hyper aware of their movements and every noise in the background. Hence my attention and focus are not where it should be. And then I will notice either my hands are shaking or sweating or I am sitting weird. So how do you work on overcoming that?

      • Maria_Morando
      • Yesterday
      • Reported - view

       I haven’t really overcome it. But I do think that recording myself a lot has helped. I record both to listen to my playing in order to critique it, and also for occasionally playing the whole piece. When I play the whole piece I am actually playing for the purpose of allowing others to hear me play. I am actually a bit nervous doing that. I keep recording the whole piece occasionally to make myself become more comfortable. I feel like I am breaking myself in slowly.  I also make it a point to play when I know people can hear me. I find comfort in knowing they aren’t totally focused on me. It is certainly a process I wish I didn’t have to do. I have a silent acoustic piano so I can play the digital capability of the piano with headphones. That is how I most often play when others are home.  I always play the acoustic when I am home alone. But sometimes I play it when others are in the house to get used to knowing others can hear. That is really helping. But I know the best thing is to jump in and get friends to come by and listen. I Haven’t had the courage to do that yet. Need to though. 

    • Yvonne_Choi
    • 8 days ago
    • Reported - view

    I focus on the music I’m creating, not on the audience. When I do that, I only care about the music itself, and I don’t get nervous. I recommend the book Beyond the Keys by JeeYoon Kim.

      • Maria_Morando
      • Yesterday
      • Reported - view

       The problem for me is I can’t seem to stop myself from thinking about the people listening.  I think I will check out the book you recommend. 

    • Else
    • 8 days ago
    • Reported - view

    As a hypnotist I work with a lot of people on performance anxiety (both music and presenting/public speaking)...it's a very common thing. Here are some things that work well for most of my clients:

    1. Decide how you want to feel when playing the piano. Of course you're probably going to have a lot of feelings, but what do you want your basic state to be? For example,  'open and focused', or 'calm and connected'. Now sit down at the piano, close your eyes and think of a time when you felt that way. Intensify the feeling, make it super vivid, give it a colour and visualise that colour going to your dominant hand. Touch the piano with with that hand and visualise the same colour flooding your body and giving you that feeling. Do it a couple of times to solidify the feeling and tell your nervous system that this is how you feel when you sit down to play. (This is called 'creating an anchor' if you want to look it up). 

    2. Yvonne Choi already mentioned this: focus not on the audience, but on the music, the gift you're giving them in being a channel for whatever wonderful piece you're playing. 

    3. Practice playing for others in a friendly setting. Organise an informal 'concert' for your neighbours. Ask them to feel free to cough, bring small kids or dogs, etc. This way you can train your nervous system to not be distracted by whatever's going on. And you may be surprised how much fun it is! 

    4. Never ever be mean to yourself when you make a mistake. It's counterproductive - it's like training a dog by beating it. Should you slip up, just keep breathing and pick things back up in whatever way you can. This tells your nervous system that it's OK to risk performing, that there is no harsh punishment waiting but the joy of sharing music instead. 

    Hope this helps, and, yes, as an intermediate amateur pianist who also happens to be a hypnotist I do still get nervous before performing - but that's not a problem. I just try to open up and do my best. 

      • Andrew_Smith
      • 5 days ago
      • Reported - view

       Hi Else and thank you for your very helpful post. I wish you could hypnotise me! I will try the anchoring exercise you describe). But in recent months I have been managing better, mostly by returning my focus to what the content of the music is about/the expression and enthusiasm for that and less about my fears of judgment.  , you have opened up a HUGE and potentially lengthy topic of discussion, but paradoxically the remedy can be simple; the best advice I ever got (the advice was from a very good performer) was, "I just really get into the feeling of the music when I play".  

    • rebecca_LAM
    • 5 days ago
    • Reported - view

    I totally feel the same way. I have to say that I have gotten better in the last year. When I say better I mean it was horrible in the past and now just not as severe as before. I watched and read so many streams and articles on this topic. But for me personally the few things that really help are: 1. Practice playing for others. Agree with starting in low pressure setting. I always signed up for the high pressure one here in tonebase community concert too and still keep messing up big time. But I am doing better with the low pressure one than before. So I figured it helps. 2. I tried David Cheng method of cold start. Play the piece you want to perform every day without warm up. If you can play through that day after day, you get better in playing through mistakes. It doesn’t matter if you have cold hands or if you just rush home from somewhere else. It helps you simulate how you may mess up and learn to fix it. 3. Pre plan jump off points when you inevitably have memory lapse or big mess up. 

      • Maria_Morando
      • Yesterday
      • Reported - view

      that sounds like good advice. I used to get so nervous that my hands would shake. Definitely not a good thing for piano playing!!  And that was just playing in front of friends. I am going to try this. 

    • rebecca_LAM
    • 4 days ago
    • Reported - view

    If anyone is ever interested in forming a small zoom group so we can regularly play for each other, please let me know. I have very few people that I can play for, so I am always looking for low pressure setting to get more practices. 

      • Andrew_Smith
      • 4 days ago
      • Reported - view

       Hi Rebecca and thank you for your two posts. I like your reminder about David Chang's method of playing a few core pieces anytime, anywhere; I'm trying to get a handful of pieces that I KNOW I can play basically clean anytime (not sure if that is possible or sustainable), so the Zoom group might be a good way for testing that and to just increase the number of times of  playing for others in low-stakes. So I might be game for a session like once every two or three weeks (I'm juggling too many musical tasks to do anything more frequent). But anyway thanks again.

      • NANCY_A_MINDEN
      • 4 days ago
      • Reported - view

      Hi Rebecca. I also would be interested in experimenting with a small zoom group to regularly play together. Even if i can play through things I'm learning in order to consolidate the early phases of my learning a piece. I'm living in Toronto - time zone is EST. We can try to put something together for max one hour - with the goal of playing- developing focus and courage. You can contact me at [email protected]. I'm also always looking for opportunities to play and share what I'm working on. Works in progress.

      • Personal trainer
      • Judy_Kuan.1
      • 4 days ago
      • Reported - view

      Great idea! I'd be interested in joining too. Like Nancy, I'm also EST time zone (in NYC). [email protected] is my email.

      • Noel_Nguyen
      • 4 days ago
      • Reported - view

       Hey Judy, I just wanted to let you know that I took the liberty to have a look at your Youtube and I can see that you've been working on this particular aspect of our craft by recording and posting progress videos for all to see. That's the way to do it! We will always experience anxiety when performing.  It is human nature, because we are social beings. Those who say they don't experience any performance anxiety are either liars or not human. The goal is to learn to live with it, and you have done tremendous work in that area, in addition to the singing beauty of your playing!

      • Personal trainer
      • Judy_Kuan.1
      • 4 days ago
      • Reported - view

       Thanks for checking out my channel! I figured the likelihood of my videos showing up (even if they're public) is roughly the same as finding a needle in a haystack. A lot of it is for my family to listen to (I think someone suggested thinking about the audience). Recording and playing live are still two very different experiences. The latter just takes much more mental preparation and less focus on "perfection". 

      • rebecca_LAM
      • 4 days ago
      • Reported - view

      Great to hear that there is interest. We can use this to support each other to learn and grow. My email is [email protected] and I am in CST. I will send out an email to reach out to Judy and Nancy. Andrew, please send me your email or email me. Hopefully they don't go to Junk mail.

      • Andrew_Smith
      • 3 days ago
      • Reported - view

      Hi Rebecca and thanks. [email protected]

      • Maria_Morando
      • Yesterday
      • Reported - view

       I may be interested in a zoom session as well. I am not technically knowledgeable at all so I may need some help getting involved. I do know that recording myself playing has helped a bit with nerves. But even recording has the ability to make me nervous and make mistakes. Recording is about as low stakes as it can get. I find that the better I can control my nerves in recording the better I get at playing with people listening. But still not as an audience. I play with them in the house able to hear me. Once I am the focus I have difficulty. But it is getting better. I still need actual listeners. 

Content aside

  • 1 Likes
  • YesterdayLast active
  • 20Replies
  • 162Views
  • 11 Following