Week 3: Keep the Momentum

By now, the challenge is getting real!

You’ve chosen your piece, spent time with it, and hopefully started to hear it take shape. But this is also the point where things can get hard. The easy excitement of beginning fades a little, and you’re left with the more important part: staying with it.

 

That’s what Week 3 is about.

Not perfection. Not having everything solved. Just continuing, even when the going gets tough.

 

Maybe you’ve hit a section that still won’t settle. Maybe progress feels slower than you hoped. Maybe you’re realizing how much more there is to do. That’s normal. In fact, it’s part of the process. This is often the exact moment when real growth happens, if you just keep showing up!

 

This week, the goal is simple: keep the moving forward!

Even a small step matters:

  • one passage a little steadier
  • one phrase a little freer
  • one practice session where you stayed patient
  • one moment where the music started to sound as you like

That is momentum.

This week, share where you are right now:

  • a short clip from your practice
  • a passage that’s improving
  • a place where you’re still stuck
  • or a few thoughts on what it’s been like to stay with the piece

And if you need, share what might be frustrating you, too.

We are all in this together.

 

Week 4 will be about recording. This week is about building the resilience to get there.

Keep going. Stay with it. You may be closer than you think.

167 replies

null
    • Noel_Nguyen
    • 1 mth ago
    • Reported - view

    Time sure goes real fast suddenly, doesn't it?

    Here is my practice video for this week. During practice I'm mostly trying to disengage my training wheels, which means my muscle memory. I don't believe muscle memory ever needs to be deliberately practiced, as it comes with the repetitions anyway. In fact, I find it better to forcefully try to disengage it during practice, in order to reinforce the other memory modalities., hence all the pauses. Most of the time I fail, but when I succeed, it reveals weak spots that would  otherwise only be revealed in performance (when it matters). I call it unmasking the devil! Remember, the devil's ultimate treachery is convincing the world the devil does not exist. So when I can unmask it during practice, it is a major victory, albeit uncomfortable, as you can see and hear in the video. (Warning: there will be screams and grunts, but the cursing has been removed.) And oh yea, there is also a head transplant. The reason for this is that I tried to replicate  's top down camera view, only to be horrified to see that my giant head was obstructing the view of the keyboard! I couldn't decapitate it, but I did plaster a picture of a random guy's head on mine, because I don't like my gray hair. The vanity! The plus side is that it makes the video more interesting, not to mention extremely funny:

      • Unfrozen Barroom Piano Player
      • Peter_G
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       I think you're doing fine by just being yourself, and your sense of humor is part of the package. And being able to laugh at oneself reflects a bit of healthy perspective on the life-and-death seriousness with which we all tend to approach our practicing and performance efforts. 

      I'm not necessarily saying that you'd want this video playing on the jumbotron during your Carnegie Hall debut, but it does no harm here in a practice video, and if anything highlights by contrast solemness and substantiality of Rachmaninoff's chordal passagework, and the work you've done to convey it in your playing.

      And I'm going through exactly the same thing with my YouTube channel.  I'm a accumulating a large library of recordings that are "not good enough" to post publicly, in contrast to a collection of exactly zero that are "good enough".  I think it may be time to show the world how I actually play, instead of waiting for that lightning stroke of luck in a performance that might create the impression that I play better than I actually can!

      • Der Wanderer
      • FRANZ_SCHUBERT
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       RE:  I think it may be time to show the world how I actually play, instead of waiting for that lightning stroke of luck in a performance that might create the impression that I play better than I actually can!

      Here, here !!!  Bravo !!!!   Well said!

      Ha ha ha.  Oops.  I like to hear others say this but I certainly need to apply these words to myself.  (this was a pep talk to myself !). Thanks Peter.

      • Noel_Nguyen
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       No worries Peter, and thanks for the support!

      I know that if I make this video public I might finally go viral, but I'll pass on this one!

      • Noel_Nguyen
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       About time someone mentioned the Chasse-Neige snippet😄. It's in the same key as the Rach Sonata after all.

      • Philosophy teacher and piano lover
      • Juan_Carlos
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       I always really enjoy your videos, Noel! They are spectacular in every sense. Bravo!! (in every sense, of course).

      • Have a growth mindset, no matter what!
      • Gail_Starr
      • 3 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       I never knew about that technique, Tammy.  Thank you!

    • Unfrozen Barroom Piano Player
    • Peter_G
    • 1 mth ago
    • Reported - view

    Arghhhh! I posted something yesterday which is still labeled "pending review", which I think means you can't see it yet.   I'm already 2 Weeks behind the rest of you.  So here's the link to my equivalent of a "Week 1" post, which will have to suffice until the Robo police decide upon my punishment**:

    So here it is, half-memorized, most of the notes learned, but not yet performable:

    Rachmaninoff Prelude in Bb Minor, Op. 32 No. 2, Unfinished

    https://youtu.be/1l_npTCcBEE

    **I'm not sure what my offense was, but I did use a common word that describes the emotional peak or high point of my piece. 

      • Akzent oder Diminuendo?
      • Maria_F
      • 1 mth ago
      • Reported - view

       I have not noticed much of a pattern to what gets flagged. I posted something a while ago and I was completely banned for a week. I still cannot think of anything I said that could have been offensive (unless they flag German-language piece titles as Denglisch, which I doubt!).

      • Unfrozen Barroom Piano Player
      • Peter_G
      • 1 mth ago
      • Reported - view

       all I dare say is perhaps I should have said “denouement” instead 

      • vbashyam
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       Love how you maintain the rhythm and intensity throughout! Great sound and video too. Just noticed the piece wood you have under your feet- I assume it’s to help with your nuanced pedaling. 

      • Unfrozen Barroom Piano Player
      • Peter_G
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       Hi Vidhya, no the cutting board on the floor has nothing to do with my pedaling technique per se.  After we got this piano in 2020, my R foot started hurting inexplicably.  My very astute wife, with 40+ years of experience as a nurse and healthcare researcher, noted that I was lifting my foot very high to reach the pedals (the piano was elevated about 1" with casters, to keep the 900 pound beast from drilling through the rug). She suggested putting the cutting board there to elevate my feet so I wouldn't have to reach as high.  Voila, the pain disappeared!  

      P.S. I'm glad to hear you like the video. I'm hoping I'll be able to improve on this and bring up the tempo before this Challenge is over.

      • Larry_K
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

          Something I posted was held as Pending for so many days that I finally wrote support. 

      • Philosophy teacher and piano lover
      • Juan_Carlos
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       Wonderful playing, Peter! I like how you shape the growing intensity and expression. Impressive!

      • Akzent oder Diminuendo?
      • Maria_F
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       Me too. I was completely locked out for over a week. 

      • Unfrozen Barroom Piano Player
      • Peter_G
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

      Maybe I should have said "Zonale Peak"

      • Unfrozen Barroom Piano Player
      • Peter_G
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       Thanks Juan Carlos; as I tried to share in my censored post, this is really a Week 1 offering. I've just started working in earnest on this piece although I did perform it some 25 years ago.  I've spent some time on specific spots and they are at that awkward point of being half-memorized where I need to look at my hands but still dare not look away from the music.

      I also don't see yet how I'm going to get the Clim-- er, "point of highest emotional tension" -- up to tempo, but I'm hoping it will find its way with enough slow practice.

      • Larry_K
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       Maximum electricity demand within an electrical grid? Your playing is energized.

      • Unfrozen Barroom Piano Player
      • Peter_G
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       perhaps I should have said "explodes in a wild paroxysm of screams and shudders and heart-palpitating leaps of limbs and fingers"  

      • hot4euterpe
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       Hi Peter - some fine work so far! You seem quite secure throughout. This prelude reminds me of the Op. 32 / 12 one in G# minor which I played a number of years ago. They both have a certain otherworldly beauty and oddness to them that really speaks to me.

      • Unfrozen Barroom Piano Player
      • Peter_G
      • 3 wk ago
      • Reported - view

       Hi Dustin, I really appreciate your feedback here. The piece is still very far from where I want it to be, but I'm somewhat sure of where I want to go interpretively -- perhaps rushing to express the interpretation before I've adequately learned the notes.  I've had trouble getting time with my piano this month, but I've worked on the memorization, and am just about ready for a "Week 2" recording.  

      I know exactly what you mean about this Prelude & the G# Minor. I must say I understand the harmonic progressions in the G# Minor --so breathtakingly beautiful as always with Rach--a little better than I do here.  There are some extremely odd and dissonant chords here.  In trying to understand them I've substituted other more conventional chords in the progressions and they definitely don't sound as good or as "right". 

      The piece is clearly tonal in character notwithstanding the dissonant and non-tertiary chords leading into the cadences.  Yes, he's moving chromatically in many places, but that still doesn't explain his choice of chords.  I can retain the chromatic line and swap out the other harmonies with more conventional Bb Minor based chords and they definitely are wrong for the scale or progression he's using. So there's a lot more going on than just chromaticism, and it seems like Sergei is working within some very definite mode of Bb Minor.  but for the life of me I can't figure out what it is!

      All of which doesn't have to interfere with performance.  If anything it enhances the chilling mysteriousness of this piece!  

    • Mary_Manuel
    • 1 mth ago
    • Reported - view

    I have just returned from an amazing trip to Montana! Needless to say, I didn't touch a piano for 8 days! Then when I got home and caught up on things....another day had gone by. Every time I looked at the piano I thought "ok, just sit down and play for crying out loud - you won't have forgotten everything" and thankfully.... very pleased was I!  Somethings even sounded better! Now that I am back in the saddle - (and I was in a saddle in Montana) I am getting caught up on lesson repertoire and the music for this challenge - Wild/Gershwin Embraceable You. My biggest challenge with this piece is mental and physical pacing. I am working on finding places to regroup mentally and physically before getting to certain rapid passages. Also continuing to bring out the melody. I am not a Jedi yet - haha!

      • Der Wanderer
      • FRANZ_SCHUBERT
      • 4 wk ago
      • Reported - view

        Re:  Wild/Gershwin Embraceable You. - As I said previously, I didn't really know this Gershwin piece intimately until recently and through the Earl Wild transcription.  Then came your post about it and recently I watched a movie called Humoresque (from 1946) with Joan Crawford that made a brief reference to it for reasons.  It made me think about how much more interesting everything becomes the more one knows about all the details and little things.  One can hear and see things and never really be aware of much.  Then, being aware eventually and suddenly you can see things in a different light.

      • Unfrozen Barroom Piano Player
      • Peter_G
      • 3 wk ago
      • Reported - view

      .   Earl Wild was an excellent concert pianist and also very conversant with jazz and popular music, and like Gershwin was devoted to bridging the gap between "classical" and "jazz/popular" music.  His arrangements are a priceless addition to the catalog.  Can't wait to hear youplay this!

    • hot4euterpe
    • 1 mth ago
    • Reported - view

    Week 3 Update - Mouvement (Images I, Debussy)

    This week's practice has been a bit frustrating as I have been unwell for much of the week and it is difficult to concentrate effectively on such challenging music when you do not feel clear-headed. My original plan for the week was to try and record a complete A and a complete B section but I realized that was going to be too big a goal, so I just focused on the complete A section. This opening section proved to be quite difficult to record to my satisfaction but I have included one of the better attempts below. I am sure it will feel a little less 'slippery' as I get back to feeling normal and have a bit more time with it to finesse some of the pedal work.

      • Akzent oder Diminuendo?
      • Maria_F
      • 1 mth ago
      • Reported - view

       I hope you feel better soon! I also have not been able to practice my piece for this challenge much, but for different reasons. 

Content aside

  • 4 Likes
  • 5 days agoLast active
  • 167Replies
  • 590Views
  • 27 Following